The L'oreal's Colour Riche Caresse Stick is a balm with different color tints.
The first thing I thought of when I saw these on Nouveaucheap's blog was that they look very similar to Revlon's lip butters. Needless to say, I had to go purchase a few of these as soon as I saw them in Target. I haven't seen them sold anywhere else and target.com does not have them for sale as of today. I purchased three shades out of the 10 or so released shades a week ago. Revlon lip butters definitely has more color in their collection. Caresse sticks retail for about $7.99, 2.9g.
left to right: velvety fuchsia, rose taffeta, sheer linen
top to bottom: velvety fuchsia, rose taffeta, sheer linen